Research Concept
In the summer of 2025, two American brands released denim advertising campaigns for the back-to-school season nearly simultaneously. On July 23, American Eagle launched the «Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans» campaign featuring actress Sydney Sweeney. On August 19, Gap released the «Better in Denim» video with the pop group KATSEYE. The product and season are the same for both brands, but their approaches differ. American Eagle leaned into a single star and a suggestive pun, and the cameras in its commercials focus on the actress’s body. Gap gathered a group of young women from different countries and filmed their dance in a bright studio set to a 2003 song. American Eagle’s advertisement was discussed across the entire country, even reaching the White House, while Gap’s video received widespread praise. The press immediately began comparing them, making this a convenient case study for research. With two advertisements for the same product released at the same time, and both companies publishing quarterly reports, it is possible to see how sales changed. For a designer, this presents an important debate: what performs better—visibility at any cost, or an image that the viewer wants to embody?

American Eagle, key visual for the «Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans» campaign, 2025
For our analysis, we are focusing on what the mass audience saw and what the press discussed the most. With American Eagle, this includes the teaser posters for «Sydney Sweeney Has Great Genes» without a logo, a billboard featuring a crossed-out word, «genes,» and the campaign videos—specifically «Genes» and «Eyes Up Here, ” which received the most criticism. For Gap, we are examining a 90-second video, the campaign photography, and a hoodie where the brand name is displayed in Gap’s signature arch. As a point of comparison, we are incorporating the older Gap video, „Khakis Swing, ” from 1998. We are not evaluating American politics or the actress herself. Our interest lies in the decisions made by the advertising creators and their resulting impact.

Gap, «Better in Denim» campaign, photo by Bjorn Iooss, 2025
First, we describe the status of the brands as of the summer of 2025. Then, we analyze both campaigns using a standardized framework. We examine the perception scenario the advertisement sets for the viewer and which psychological triggers it activates. Following this, we dissect the frame, gaze, color, and composition. Afterward, we validate the hypothesis with data and suggest areas for improvement. Our primary sources of work are the quarterly filings for SEC, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. We also utilize industry publications like Adweek, Ad Age, Marketing Dive, and Retail Brew, along with YouGov surveys, Google Trends data, and academic research on advertising. If figures in the sources conflict, we prioritize data from the official filings. Companies calculate and do not disclose data on impressions and new customers, so we mark those figures as self-reported data.
The central question of the work is simple: What sells jeans better—a scandal or a dance? Our hypothesis is this: the scandal brought American Eagle attention and a rise in stock prices, but it didn’t increase jean sales. Gap increased jean sales because its commercial was something people wanted to imitate. We are testing this through brand sales, stock performance, search queries, and viewer surveys.
The Summer of Denim War
In the spring of 2025, sales at American Eagle were declining. The company wrote off $75 million in unsold merchandise, and the campaign with Suin was the most expensive in its history. Gap, meanwhile, was navigating a decade of decline. Richard Dixon, who previously revitalized Barbie at Mattel, has led the company since 2023. By the summer of 2025, the Gap brand had been growing for the seventh consecutive quarter.
CHRONOLOGY07.23.2025 American Eagle launches campaign with Sydney Sweeney
07.25–07.27 eugenics accusations and repost wave
08.04 Trump’s post, American Eagle stock up 23,7% in one day
08.19 Gap releases video with KATSEYE
08.28 and 11.20 Gap reports
09.03 and 12.02 American Eagle reports
Both advertisements tapped into the trend of Y2K aesthetics and low-rise fashion. Leading up to August 2025, women’s low-rise jeans sales had increased by 132% (Circana). During this period in the United States, cultural debates were prominent, meaning the advertisements could spark a political controversy in just a couple of days. Even the initial shots in both ads are similar; in them, the jeans sit low on the hips.
Left: American Eagle, «Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans» video, 2025. Right: Gap, «Better in Denim» video, 2025.
The marks started from different points, so let’s see where the numbers have shifted.
American Eagle Pun
American Eagle, banner «Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans», 2025
Initially, posters without a logo bearing the phrase «Sydney Sweeney Has Great Genes”—meaning „Sydney Sweeney has excellent genes”—were hung in New York. Then, the word „genes“ was crossed out and manually written over with „jeans.“ In the video, Sweeney herself performs this action with a paint roller. In the video, while discussing heredity and eye color, she concludes with the phrase, „My jeans are blue.“ In English, this phrase can sound like „my jeans are blue“ or „my genes are blue.“
American Eagle, «Posters up. Secrets out,» 2025
A pun functions like a psychological trigger. The double meaning compels the reader to reread the phrase, and many interpreted the word «genes» alongside the platinum blonde, blue-eyed star as an allusion to «ideal» appearance. Marketing Director Craig Brommers had promised before the launch that the campaign would «push buttons.» Two days later, the advertisement was accused of promoting eugenics, yet Trump praised the video on August 4th.
+23.7%This is how much American Eagle stock grew in a single day—August 4, 2025—after Trump’s post. This is the strongest one-day increase since 2000.
The advertisement dictated a framework for the viewer to «debate and judge.» They argued about genes and politics.
Camera in American Eagle Reels
In the «Genes» video, the camera slowly pans up Суини’s body. First, the shot focuses on her hips in jeans, then her waist and chest, and only at the very end, her blue eyes, matching the denim. In the «Eyes up here» video, according to Adweek, the camera focuses on the chest until the actress tells the operator, «Hey, eyes up here.» In 1975, Laura Malvy termed this technique the «male gaze"—the camera looking at a woman through a man’s eyes.
American Eagle, «Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans» video, 2025
In the video featuring the Ford Mustang, the camera also lingers on the back pockets of the jeans. The advertisement did not hide that it was aimed at men. Suini, dressed in men’s jeans, stood in the men’s department displays; the videos appeared on Reddit and in sports media. The actress captures the viewer’s attention. According to Brainsight’s model, the face receives 40% of the attention on the poster, while the brand receives 15%. In the 15-second video, the «Gens» logo only appears at the 13th second.
American Eagle, campaign video with Ford Mustang, 2025
American Eagle, video «Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans,» 2025. The logo appears at the 13th second.
Brainsight, attention forecast for the American Eagle poster, 2026
Researchers call this the «vampire effect.» A bright celebrity captures the attention that was meant for the brand.
Gap Viral Dance
The Gap video is 90 seconds long. Six girls from KATSEYE, dressed head-to-toe in denim, and around thirty dancers, mostly in black and brown, dance in a bright studio to Kelis' 2003 hit, «Milkshake.» Gap has been using this technique for a long time. In 1998, for the «Khakis Swing» video, Gap models also danced the swing in khaki pants against a white background.




