Original size 2375x3333

Designed to Die: Industrial Design and Planned Obsolescence in the Fashion Industry

PROTECT STATUS: not protected
The project is taking part in the competition

Navigation Menu

1. Introduction 1.1. Conceptual Framework and Hypothesis 2. Industrial Design as an Architect of Obsolescence 2.1. From Sketch to Final Product 2.2. Materials 2.3. Sewing Processes 2.4. Flexible Supply Chains 2.5. Design for Non-repairability 3. Who Benefits from This System?The Beauty of a Well-Made Thing Conclusion

Introduction: The Wardrobe as a Symptom

There is an object that almost everyone had and almost no one remembers. A completely ordinary thing, put away for one summer and forgotten at the bottom of a drawer. Then, one day, without any ceremony, it ends up in the trash. People don’t remember it because it wasn’t created to be remembered. And that, perhaps, best explains the whole story. It’s not about clothes tearing; it’s about them being designed—and I mean in the most technical, not metaphorical, sense of the word—in a way that leaves no trace.

post

Shirts from past generations still hang in country closets—patched with threads of another color, featuring buttons that don’t match. The original is lost, and someone has sewn on a button they found handy. Such a shirt tells a story. A polyester T-shirt bought last month for a price that doesn’t reflect the entire chain of processes behind its appearance on store shelves usually tells nothing. It doesn’t live long enough to even tell about itself.

It has become commonplace to say that we live in a disposable age. People repeat this phrase with the same resignation they use when talking about the weather or traffic jams—as if it were a natural phenomenon rather than a decision made by someone in some office, over a spreadsheet. This is where the fundamental error in much of the discourse about fast fashion lies: the blame is assigned to trends, to social media, to volatile youth who have supposedly forgotten how to value things. But the problem is not solely, or even primarily, that an entire generation has lost its way, blindly following what others dictate to buy and what to reject.

big
Original size 4000x2250
post

Long before a teen discovers Pinterest or any other social network, catches sight of an item, finds it on a marketplace, and receives it the very next day, someone decided that this object would last no longer than one season. This decision wasn’t made intentionally, but rather as a result of the cumulative technical, manufacturing, and economic decisions that, in the broadest sense, constitute what is called industrial design.

From the outset, it is necessary to clarify a nuance that will be central to this essay. To speak of industrial design as a cause of obsolescence does not mean to accuse the designer of being in a conspiracy against durability. Industrial design, understood correctly, represents the outcome of a collective and hierarchical process. Sketches, prototypes, and creative solutions are involved, but so are budgets, profitability margins, production constraints, and often directives coming from finance departments far removed from any aesthetic calling.

The author argues that the impermanence of modern clothing is not a side effect of consumerism, but the result of a chain of decisions spanning design, creative direction, procurement, and financial control. The end product of this chain is an item designed not to survive the temptation of being replaced.

Original size 4000x2250

Conceptual Framework and Hypothesis: What Isn’t Fixed Isn’t Liked

Jiles Slade (Slade, 2006) gave a name to something that decades had hinted at, yet failed to fully articulate: there are things created to die. He termed this planned obsolescence and delineated three forms of this declared demise. The first is technical obsolescence: a component fails precisely when the warranty expires. The second is aesthetic: an object functions flawlessly, but suddenly feels awkward to wear because something newer has arrived on the market. This is why wide ties sit in closets—it’s a shame to discard them, yet impossible to wear. The third is incompatibility obsolescence: a charger that no longer fits, a spare part that has been discontinued, or a stitch technique that no one knows how to execute anymore.

Original size 4000x2250

What truly concerns me is something else: contemporary clothing does not adhere to any single form. Instead, it practices all of them simultaneously, with almost choreographic discipline. Fast fashion is designed to lose its appeal (aesthetic obsolescence). It is also designed to fray before it becomes unfashionable (technical obsolescence). And when someone attempts to repair it, there will be no excess fabric, no extra thread, and no tailor willing to charge less than its original price (obsolescence due to unreparability). This is the state of clothing today.

Viktor Papanek wrote a sentence in 1971 that has never lost its relevance: design is the conscious planning of order, and such planning is always, first and foremost, an ethical act, and only then an aesthetic one. Papanek intuitively grasped what this essay aims to demonstrate using textiles: industrial design, both as a discipline and as a process, determines how long an object will exist in the world with every choice of material and technology. The beauty of an object is the least significant part of its destiny in this sense. What determines it is something else—something quieter: the fabric density, the type of stitch, the adhesive or the seam on a boot sole, the miles the fabric travels from the factory to the port and finally to the storefront. Above all, there is the question of who had the final say on each of these decisions.

Отсюда вытекает гипотеза, на которой держится
всё эссе:

«The obsolescence of modern clothing is the result of deliberate choices in industrial design: selecting non-durable materials, simplifying sewing processes, and creating items that are not repairable. These decisions are aimed at maximizing inventory turnover. It is these factors—not cultural trends—that form the underlying structural cause, which is subsequently legitimized and solidified by accelerated consumption.»

In other words, rapid consumption is not because the consumer is superficial. It is rapid because long before the consumer enters the store, the chain of technical and financial solutions has already built a world where only that speed is possible. If we look more broadly, clothes used to be made slowly, and few could afford to change them so often. The reason wasn’t just the materials, but the sewing process itself: garments were tailored individually, and people loved their clothes. Therefore, they lasted for decades, and the minor flaws that were repaired spoke more of love and timelessness. Today, it is so easy to replace something that people no longer try to fix it; they simply swap it for a new one.

Industrial Design as the Architect of Obsolescence

From Sketch to Final Product

Before analyzing materials, processes, and supply chains, one must address a fact that often remains invisible in discussions about sustainable fashion. Major fashion retailers operate in departments, and the designer rarely decides what material an item they designed will be made from. They might suggest it, because the idea originates with them. But this is where the first dilemma begins: in order to lower costs, something has to be sacrificed.

Major players sacrifice labor. Companies like Inditex and H&M do this by moving production to countries with cheap labor. Others sacrifice materials: fabrics and blends become lower quality. In most cases, they sacrifice both, as is the case with Shein.

The typical workflow in the industry needs restoration. A designer conceives an item, often with meticulous aesthetic and technical development—sometimes almost artisanal—and translates it into a sketch and technical specification. Then, the sketch goes through creative direction, which may adjust the style. But the most crucial step is passing through the cost department’s filter: purchasing, production, and often accounting. It is in this stage, rather than at the designer’s desk, that the quiet substitution most frequently occurs. The suggested fabric is swapped for a cheaper one, the lining disappears or is replaced, an reinforced seam is simplified, and metal hardware gives way to plastic or simply less expensive alternatives.

Such decisions are regularly documented in industry research on garment production (McKinsey & Company, 2022). They do not always originate from top management and do not necessarily follow a «break it to fix it» strategy. More often, they arise from more prosaic directives: do not exceed the permissible loss threshold. These directives come from finance departments that are far removed from any design decisions.

Ultimately, the finished product—the item that ends up in the store—can differ significantly from the designer’s initial concept, and the designer often has no real ability to prevent this. The system of accountability is not absolved; rather, responsibility is distributed more precisely: the problem lies not with the will of a single creative individual, but with the organizational structure where the short-term financial metric systematically holds the final say over the long-term technical criterion of durability. Industrial design, as the final product specification, is the result of uneven negotiations among creativity, production, and accounting. In these discussions, durability rarely has its own voice at the decision-making table.

Materials: Fragility Engineering

There is something almost honest about the coarseness of polyester: it never promised anything. It is cheap, versatile, can be dyed any imaginable color, and today it accounts for over fifty-four percent of all textile fiber produced worldwide (Textile Exchange, 2022).

But polyester’s memory is short. It pills, loses its shape, and degrades in the sun with an ease that no natural fiber possesses. Its choice is almost always dictated by the purchasing department to meet the cost parameters set by the financiers. It is an engineering solution—as precise as choosing stainless steel for a scalpel. The only difference is that here, the precision aims for the minimum acceptable service life, not the maximum.

Blended fabrics are even more telling—that cotton-polyester mix worn unknowingly by a significant portion of humanity. In these materials, the calculation becomes almost involuntarily cynical. The blend improves tactile properties and lowers the cost, while simultaneously dooming the garment to irrecyclability: modern processes cannot separate intermingled fibers (Ellen MacArthur Foundation, 2017).

The issue isn’t that someone decided at the very beginning of the design process to deny the item a second life. Rather, somewhere in the supply chain, no one who could have made the decision prioritized recycling. The fabric composition itself closed off that possibility—and no conscious discussion ever took place.

Sewing Processes: Simplification as a Strategy

If you compare the cuff of a shirt from fifty years ago with the cuff of a t-shirt bought last week, the difference will be substantial. The first has excess fabric and a double stitch reinforcing thread. The second only has the bare minimum: a single stitch, cut precisely to the pattern’s edge, without an extra centimeter in case the garment ever needs to be enlarged or lengthened. This isn’t carelessness; it’s cost engineering pushed to its logical extreme, and it is transparently documented in industry reports (McKinsey & Company, 2022). Every second of a seamstress’s time costs money; every centimeter of fabric costs money. This savings, which is rarely decided by the person who initially designed the item, results in a product engineered for a short lifespan within its budget lines. Then it must be replaced with a new one, creating an infinite loop (Fashion Revolution, 2021).

Agile Supply Chains: The Logic of Short Lead Times

Companies like Zara or Shein have perfected not fashion, but time. They built a mechanism capable of taking a design from sketch to storefront in less than two weeks. The traditional industry required six to nine months for this (Caro & Martínez-de-Albéniz, 2015).

To achieve this, they produce small batches, track real-time sales data, and only reorder what is performing well. Essentially, it is a nervous system that senses market signals and responds with almost no conscious intervention.

This architecture is also industrial design, although it operates at the level of the system rather than an individual object. It is designed not for clothing to last long, but for the entire system to remain viable, even if it means that every part—every single item—becomes disposable.

Designed to Die: Industrial Design and Planned Obsolescence in the Fashion Industry
Project created at 15.11.2026
adcr.dafes
The Art Directors Club of Russia sets the benchmark for creative excellence in design and advertising, serving as a central hub where industry professionals connect. Since 2004, the Club has hosted the ADCR Awards—a premier national competition celebrating creativity, design, and advertising. The core mission of the awards is to champion agencies and independent creators making their mark in the local market. By presenting this honor on behalf of the professional community, the Club reaffirms its endur... Show more
adcr advertising
adcr design
adcr students and young creators